
A Note from MutStack Owner Dave Portnoy
Congratulations to Fasoli on getting married
What a year for Fasoli! A LeBron callout and marrying the love of his life in the span of just a few months.
Huge congrats to Nick and the bride-to-be. Wishing you a lifetime of love and happiness…and many more Pats Super Bowls!
It actually felt like there had been a ceasefire between Joe Buck and Troy Aikman.
Buck took a new deal this past spring without telling Troy, even when ESPN told him he might not be working with his long-time partner anymore. Troy had to find out through the media. They had a pre-game argument in October. Both sides leaked their own version of the story for about a week after. Troy, of course, has no new deal with ESPN and is set to be a free agent after the season. But with the guys slated to call a playoff game plus Super Bowl 61, my sense was that they had agreed to stop the fight and make it work through February 14th in LA.
“I know Joe always wanted a one-man booth.” 💣💥💣
Then Troy said this on Dallas radio Thursday. And with that, I’d say there’s no longer a 100% chance that the two are calling the Super Bowl together. Crazy.
We’re 86 days away from that date - which you can argue is one of the biggest days in ESPN’s history. ABC has had the Super Bowl, but ESPN? This is their first. It’s a HUGE deal - one that comes with alt-casts and promotion and a whole lot of pomp and circumstance.
Of course, there will be a TON of media coverage. Do you really think that they want to deal with a Rogue Aikman ripping Buck and ESPN on his way out the door? There’s a chance Buck v. Aikman becomes one of the biggest stories of the week. Based on Thursday, how could they trust Aikman NOT to make it a big story?
Firing him now (or paying him to walk away and not talk about it in the media) seems crazy, until you weigh the possibility of ESPN dealing with this as a major distraction during its Super Bowl Week.
The great Nick Kostos of You Better You Bet, Westwood One, WFAN, and more, is as obsessed with this stuff as I am. And he knows the business. I texted him before his show Friday and told him I didn’t think we'd get these guys calling the Super Bowl 100%, and I wanted to know what percentage he’d put it at.
“49%.”
Wow!
Can you get through the rest of the regular season and playoffs with, say, Buck and Jason Kelce? Is Greg Olson’s deal up after he calls his last playoff game? Is it crazy for Buck/Olson to have their first game be Super Bowl 61?
Yeah, sounds crazy, I know. That’s why I’d be higher than Kostos, say 75%, Buck/Aikman call the game. But that’s still a 25% chance they don’t. I could see ESPN going to Aikman, asking him to chill out, and giving him some money to do so. Will Aikman play along? Does he already have his next job lined up, either in TV or with an NFL team? Is he so pissed he’s just trying to burn it all down? After yesterday’s Aikman assault, I have no clue how this is going to play out.
But I do know it’s no lock they last the season - and that the opening of Bengals/Commanders this Monday Night is now must-see stuff.
Meanwhile, I have thoughts on Drake Maye and the Pats. We have a MutStack Review of the new movie, ‘Madden.’ Plus NFL Picks, Notes, and so much more.
All ahead in Friday Four-Pack #198.
Hey! Subscribe and join the over 7,000 others who get the Four-Pack emailed to them every Friday.
It’s a huge help when you do subscribe.
Also, still FREE ⬇️⬇️⬇️
On the Patriots and Drake Maye…
Seriously, what is going on?
On ‘Madden,’ out now on Amazon Prime…

The early trailers for ‘Madden,’ out this week on Amazon Prime and starring Nicolas Cage as John Madden, looked really bad. The early reviews from critics and fans followed suit. Like, really bad. Rotten Tomatoes has it at 15% on its Tomatometer as of early Friday, with 28 of the 33 reviews ranking it Rotten.
No real spoilers below, I don’t think, but it is a review…
I loved John Madden in the booth. First with Pat Summerall, then with Al Michaels. I played hundreds of hours of Madden in high school and college - and now my kids play basically every day. My memories of Madden are 100% positive. And I like football. So yeah, I hoped that reviews were just being hypercritical and that Madden would be a good alternative to watching Colts/Texans on Thursday Night Football.
It’s just not any good. I’ll try and explain why in a second. But it does have some redeeming qualities.
There are some decent acting performances. Notably, Christian Bale is getting some love for the way that he played Raiders Owner Al Davis. I agree he was pretty good. I thought Kathryn Hahn, playing John’s wife Virginia Madden, gave the second-best performance of the movie. Joel Murray as Summerall plays.
There are a few laughs, I guess. Cage and Bale have some solid scenes together. Shane Gillis as Madden’s wacky neighbor made me chuckle. The first shot of fake Mark Davis is pretty funny.
The rest of it? Hot garbage.
Cage as Madden doesn’t work visually. The voice doesn’t play. And I don’t know if this was the plan, but he plays Madden like a simpleton at times - like he’s a complete dunce and incapable of functioning in real life, outside football.
I wasn’t alive for those 70s Raiders teams, and I know this wasn’t a real biopic, but I assumed they got that part right. Guess not? Yikes.
The whole thing comes across as so cartoony. If it’s supposed to be some sort of parody and be BIG and LOUD, like Madden was in the booth, it doesn’t work. There are little things that annoy me - like the movie showing Madden in the booth in 1980, using his telestrator, but then they use an NFL on Fox clip from the 90s. The actual football in the movie is gross. The Bob Costas character is useless. The movie just slows to a dead stop at one point. But to their credit, they save the worst for last.
There's a long scene late in the movie with the terrible John Mulvaney character, who works for EA Sports and is trying to get Madden on board for the video game, and it's truly horrific. Mulvaney’s character is brutal. The dumb cameos from Marshawn Lynch and Julian Edelman are 0% funny. I was starting to doze off at this point, but I got so angry at the way this scene plays out that I powered through to the end, thanks in part to it. Awful, borderline offensive stuff.
Madden was hired as the head coach of the Raiders at age 32. He worked for one of the craziest owners in sports. The guy never had a losing season in the NFL. He went on to be an iconic broadcaster and the face of one of the most popular video games ever. He had a huge personality. And you got Cage and Bale on board and invested here. A great story + good acting could have made for a decent movie.
It doesn’t. Not even close. It falls short of that in pretty much every way.
1.5 ⭐s out of 4 (Four-Pack of Stars? Get it?) Should you watch? Probably not. Will it get better with age? I don’t know how. Will I rewatch? No chance.
On a four-pack of Week 11 NFL Picks…

WEEK 10 RESULTS: 1-2, NO ATD WINNER
SEASON RESULTS: 12-16-1, 1 ATD, 1 DraftKings early exit
SEASON ATD: 1 for 10 (Odds of 7-1)
I can’t believe the Colts didn’t cover. Getting 2.5-1 on Beck 2+ INTS is good for the ROI but less helpful for the overall record. Lines from the world’s best sportsbook, DraftKings, as of Thursday Night.
The Side
BRONCOS (-10.5) VS. RAIDERS (-105)
Even if Brock Bowers plays, I’m okay laying double-digits against the Raiders. But if he sits, I love this play. The Broncos are off their bye, and Action Network has a million trends pointing you to Denver. Mendoza looked fine last week, but first-year starting QBs making their first start in Denver: 17-26-2 ATS. In the last 20 home games, Denver is 18-2 SU and 16-4 ATS. Sean Payton is great with extra rest. Meanwhile, the Raiders are 30th in DVOA defense, and with a big primetime game against the Browns next week, this game has real blowout potential. Gre
The Total
GIANTS VS. JAGS UNDER 46.5 (-106)
On paper? This is the best game of a crappy Sunday slate. But unless these two defenses melt down at MetLife, it’s likely to play slow. Sharp Football has the Jags (slowest) and Giants (6th slowest) as teams that are using a lot of the play clock in neutral situations (up or down a TD either way). They’re 24th and 25th in pass rate in those same neutral situations. Looks like legit rain in the forecast for Sunday afternoon right around kickoff. I kinda like the Giants to cover here too, but UNDER is officially the play.
The Prop
TYLER SHOUGH 20+ RUSHING YARDS (+113)
Saints QB has 16 carries for 76 yards over the last two weeks and has covered his number five times this season. Running for his life in the rain against the Bears? 20+ at +113 seems like a very fair number.
The ATD
MIKE GESICKI +190
Commanders have given up 10 TD catches to opposing TEs this season, and the MVP chase is on for Joe Burrow.

On your weekly MutStack Notes…
⛳ At one point Tuesday, my entire X.com For You feed was Kirk Minihane vs. the Internet Invitational. As I wrote last Friday of the finale, “…it was a good reminder of why Kirk 100% NEEDS to be part of the event in 2027. Should have been in the last two years….Dave has said over and over that he doesn't pick the players himself, but hopefully he’ll remember that moment when next year's field is being discussed.”
Sounds like Whit would agree. Maybe Jerry can broker a meeting between Robby Berger and Kirk? Dave said this week that “The first year Kirk is in the Invitational will be the last year it happens.” After this week, I’m convinced he plays in the event next year. Outside of a major celebrity or PGA Pro, no one would bring more additional buzz to the event - that was obvious given the Tuesday social media reaction. And it would be great.
I’d make it +700 that he plays in it next year. And he should.
🚗 An otherwise fun lunch Thursday with Kirk, Bill from Milton’s (The Store for Men), and Cullinane was ruined by this Dave parking job. How do you do this? There will be claims that I was “terrible” at lunch, but that’s 100% false. I was throwing 98 MPH on the black. Bill is a MutStack subscriber, of course. He skims; he doesn’t read the whole thing, like most of you. Nothing wrong with that. I’ll look like a million bucks next week at Thanksgiving thanks to Bill and Milton’s. My son Carter got his first Milton’s suit this summer, and it won’t be his last. I’ll be back for more holiday shopping, and you should be too.
👀 “Do not touch or unplug.” That was my favorite part of Season 3/Episode 2 of The Case. Is Dave kind of a co-host now?
⚾ Between signing Jake Bauers and not signing Sonny Gray, I’d say it’s been a pretty good start to the Red Sox offseason for Craig Breslow. A Jarren Duran trade would be a good next move.
🎮 Call me an old man, but the Mut Boys will not be getting GTA 6. Adults who said they took the day off from work to play were just kidding, right?
🏈 Looks like a great Saturday for a UConn football tailgate.
🏀 Annoying loss to Arizona, but nothing changed for me - this team feels like a Final Four team for America’s best basketball coach, Dan Hurley.
That feels like enough Stack for this week.
Back Saturday with the weekly horse racing blog at Barstool. Good luck with all your bets this weekend. And thanks for reading - and watching.










Yes, there will be a MutStack Next week.
no radio news this week, smh.